Why Promise Rings Are Bad

Photo of author

By Oluwaseun Bamisile


Wondering why some people consider promise rings a bad thing? This article aims at providing insights into this common perspective.

I will start this piece with a section that explains what this commitment ring is all about. Then, we will explore several reasons individuals think the ring is not good.

Finally, our FAQ section will address common questions relating to the topic.

What Is A Promise Ring

What Is A Promise Ring

A promise ring is a piece of jewelry that someone gives to another person as a symbol of commitment. It is often given in romantic relationships but can also be given between friends.

The purpose of a promise ring is to express a specific promise or intention. It can represent various things depending on the individuals involved, as hinted by theknot.com.

For example, in a romantic relationship, the ring can symbolize the oath to be faithful or to get engaged or married eventually. Hence, it serves as a visible reminder of the devotion between the two people.

However, it’s important to note that a promise ring differs from an engagement ring. An engagement ring is typically given as a formal proposal for marriage.

Meanwhile, a promise ring signifies a commitment without necessarily indicating plans for engagement or marriage.

Reasons Promise Rings Are Not Good

While this ring can hold sentimental value for some people, certain perspectives suggest they are not good. Here are a few reasons some people might consider the ring bad.

1. Unrealistic Expectations

Ladymanson.com hints that promise rings can create unrealistic expectations or pressures in a relationship. When someone gives or receives this ring, it may imply a higher level of commitment.

It may also imply plans that both individuals may not be ready for.

This can lead to emotional strain and a sense of obligation that might not match the natural progression of the relationship.

2. Hinders Personal Growth

Promise rings can be seen as detrimental to personal growth within a relationship for a few reasons. Firstly, when the ring is exchanged, it can create a feeling of being “locked in” to the relationship, according to ericajewels.com.

This may limit an individual’s exploration of personal goals, interests, and self-discovery. Essentially, the focus on the ring and the commitment it represents may overshadow the importance of personal development.

Besides, the pressure associated with promise rings can lead individuals to make compromises that don’t align with their personal growth. They might feel obligated to prioritize the relationship above their ambitions, dreams, or personal boundaries.

This can negatively impact their well-being and hinder personal progress.

3. Misinterpretation Of Intentions

This ring can have different meanings to different people. One person might view it as a pre-engagement symbol.

Meanwhile, the other might see it as a gesture of exclusivity. This difference in interpretation can lead to misunderstandings and disappointments.

Therefore, it’s essential to have open and clear communication about the intentions and expectations behind the promise ring. This ensures both individuals are on the same page.

4. Emotional Manipulation

In some cases, people use promise rings as a manipulative tool within a relationship. The act of giving this ring can be used as a way to influence the other person’s behavior or emotions.

For instance, the giver might use the ring to pressure the recipient into staying in the relationship or conforming to their desires. This can create an unhealthy power dynamic and emotional dependency.

5. Temporary Solution

Promise rings can be seen as a temporary fix within a relationship, offering a superficial solution to deeper issues. By exchanging this ring, couples may attempt to address insecurities without fully resolving them.

So, instead of delving into the root causes of relationship issues, the rings can serve as a band-aid solution, as suggested by cwordsworth.com. They provide a temporary sense of reassurance without necessarily addressing the underlying concerns within the relationship.

Thus, by relying solely on the symbolism of this ring, couples may avoid taking the necessary actions to foster genuine growth. It can create a false sense of security without actually addressing the root causes of any conflicts.

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions
1. Which Finger Do Promise Rings Go On?

According to brides.com, people wear this ring on the ring finger. People mostly recognize the ring finger as the fourth finger from the thumb on the left hand.

2. What Is The Age Limit For A Promise Ring?

While this ring is often associated with teenagers, it has no age limit. Therefore, anyone at any age can have the ring.

3. Is Promise Ring The Same As An Engagement Ring?

No, a promise ring is not the same as an engagement ring. While both types of rings symbolize a commitment, they have different meanings and contexts.

A promise ring is given as a symbol of a promise or commitment between two individuals. It can represent various promises, such as fidelity, love, or a future intention to marry or engage each other.

On the other hand, an engagement ring is specifically given as a formal proposal for marriage. It represents a mutual agreement and intention to marry.

4. Does A Promise Ring Lead To Marriage?

This ring doesn’t necessarily lead to marriage. It is basically a sign of deep commitment to a relationship.  

5. Do Men Wear Promise Rings?

People often consider this ring type exclusive to women. However, the truth is that anyone can wear it, including men.


Promise rings can hold sentimental value and meaning for many individuals. However, there are several reasons why some people perceive them as negative aspects.

Nonetheless, it is important to note that these perspectives reflect common criticisms and concerns. Hence, they may not apply to every situation or relationship.

Ultimately, the decision to exchange this commitment ring depends on the individuals involved and the dynamics of their relationship. Nevertheless, it’s vital for couples to openly discuss their intentions, expectations, and concerns surrounding the rings.

Doing so ensures that they are a healthy and mutually agreed-upon choice.

We trust that the information in this article has been helpful to you. If you found it beneficial, we kindly request you to share it with your friends and family on social media.

Finally, if you wish to explore more articles on similar topics, we invite you to visit our Relationships page.

References And Further Reading

  1. cwordsworth.com – Why Promise Rings Are Bad? What Is the True Meaning?
  2. hunzabazar.com – Why are promise rings bad? (Is it Real?)
  4. medium.com – Why Promise Rings Are Bad: Exploring the Negative Side
  5. ladymanson.com – Is It True That Promise Rings Are Bad?
  6. theknot.com – What Is a Promise Ring? The Real Meaning and Purpose
  7. brides.com – What Is a Promise Ring and What Does It Symbolize?

About the Author

Photo of author

Oluwaseun Bamisile

Oluwaseun is the Lead Content Editor at Ilifeguides.com. He holds a National Diploma in Computer Science (currently studying part-time for his Higher National Diploma). An internet geek with a love for automobiles, he writes relationship articles, travel guides, and general life hacks on the site.

Related Articles

Get in Touch

We're committed to writing accurate content that informs and educates. To learn more, read our Content Writing Policy, Content Review Policy, Anti-plagiarism Policy, and About Us.

However, if this content does not meet your expectations, kindly reach out to us through one of the following means:

  1. Respond to "Was this page helpful?" above
  2. Leave a comment with the "Leave a Comment" form below
  3. Email us at [email protected] or via the Contact Us page.

Leave a Comment

Send this to a friend