How to Choose Between Two Guys

Photo of author

By Timileyin Olanrewaju


Are you looking to choose between two guys, but find it confusing? Well, this article aims to assist you with a guide on selecting between two men.

I will begin the article by discussing when it feels right to make your choice. Following that, I will highlight some key factors to consider before deciding between the two guys.

Finally, we give you a FAQ section that answers common questions that pertain to the topic.

When It Feels Right to Decide

When It Feels Right to Decide

It is never easy to choose between two guys that you genuinely find attractive and have feelings for. Some people refer to this situation as a two-guy dilemma, in which you are unsure of whom to choose.

This situation becomes more challenging, especially when both men possess similar qualities or characteristics. However, regardless of your feelings for both men, you will have to make a choice at some point.

Ideally, the right time to decide between two guys is when you are certain about what you desire in a romantic relationship. At this point, you can confidently make the right decision after evaluating both men’s qualities and how they align with your values and relationship desires.

In a case where you feel pressure from either of the guys for a more committed relationship, do not rush into a decision. Take your time to evaluate your feelings and be honest with yourself.

Hints for Selecting Between Two Men

Deciding between two guys could be daunting and tiring. However, you may find it less stressful when you have some practical steps to take.

Below are some useful tips for selecting between two men.

1. Observe Their Respective Red Flags

In any romantic relationship, it’s vital to recognize potential warning signs that could lead to serious problems. This is quite helpful, especially when you’re faced with deciding between two guys.

Therefore, pay close attention to their behavior, particularly looking for signs of rudeness, insensitivity, or disrespect. Additionally, consider whether either of them has a history of trust issues or insecurity.

Whatever the case may be, you have to determine which red flags are deal-breakers for you and act accordingly. As per, keenly observing their habits can help you detect warning signs that do not favor a long-term relationship.

2. Assess Their Supportiveness

Emotional support is a vital aspect of any successful relationship, and it runs deep. According to, receiving emotional support improves your mental health, deepens the bond, and facilitates conflict resolution.

Hence, it makes sense when selecting between two men to check who is the most supportive. To make the right choice, assess which of these men uplifts and motivates you.

As suggests, a romantic relationship involves mutual support during challenges. In essence, assessing their supportiveness involves recognizing who plays a more positive role in your life, both emotionally and physically.

3. Consider Their Personalities

Every individual has a distinct personality that reflects their traits, behaviors, and values. Hence, deciding between two guys can be daunting, as it involves evaluating their distinct personalities.

In short, you want to make sure their traits or values align with yours on a long-term basis. For instance, if you’re an introvert and one of the men is all about big parties, there could be a personality clash.

Alternatively, you may discover one of the men to be manipulative, constantly aggressive, or lack proper conflict management. Whether you observe positive or negative personality traits, evaluate whether these men’s personalities align with your vision and goals.

4. Ask About Their Future Plans And Goals

Checking future compatibility is also crucial when deciding between two guys. Therefore, it’s best to have an honest conversation with them to gain insight into their aspirations and ambitions.

For instance, if you desire commitment and a family, you must find out if either man shares similar thoughts. As suggests, learn if these men want a family or prefer traveling and assess whether their life choices align with yours.

Ideally, your goals should align with your partner’s for a fulfilling relationship. Hence, knowing their respective goals and plans becomes paramount when selecting between two men.

5. Know Where You Feel Most Secure

When choosing between two guys, you should consider where you feel safe, comfortable, and have a sense of security. To determine the right one, evaluate who is reliable, trustworthy, and respectful.

Furthermore, consider the man who is emotionally supportive, an active listener, and a good communicator. These are important factors that can contribute to your sense of security in a relationship.

Therefore, you should keep these factors in mind when making your decision. You should also recognize which aspects of each man align best with your emotional needs, values, and sense of well-being.

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions
1. What Are Red Flags In A Guy?

Red flags in a guy are warning signs or bad behaviors that may indicate an unhealthy relationship. While red flags can be subjective, some major red flags include disrespect, overly controlling behavior, narcissism, and emotional and physical abuse.

2. How Do You Know If A Guy Is Trustworthy?

To determine if a guy is trustworthy, observe his behavior and actions over time. You should look at factors like consistency in his behavior, transparency, accountability, and empathy, among others.

3. How Do You Choose Who To Date Between Two Guys?

Deciding who to date depends on your personal taste or preference. In that sense, follow your instincts and date someone with whom you are most comfortable.

Also, consider personality traits, lifestyles, compatibility with shared values, goals, and interests.

4. Can A Man Love 2 Woman At The Same Time?

Yes, it is possible for a man to love two women at the same time. According to, one in fifteen people has been in a polyamorous relationship, loving more than one person.

5. Is It Okay To Date Two Guys At The Same Time?

It’s okay as long as you’re honest and transparent with both parties. Be mindful of their feelings and ensure open communication.


Navigating a romantic relationship with two guys can be quite challenging. Furthermore, choosing between them for a long-term committed relationship can be difficult, especially when they share similar qualities.

When in this situation, you might be unsure of the right course of action. That’s why this article discusses when to make your choice and offers helpful tips for selecting between these two men.

Ultimately, you’ll need to make a decision, keeping in mind that making a choice is better than remaining indecisive.

We hope you find this article insightful and worthwhile. If you do, we encourage you to share it with your friends on your favorite social media platforms.

For more articles on relationships and similar topics, please visit our Relationship page.

References and Further Reading

  1. – 20 Tips on How to Choose Between Two Guys
  3. – How to Choose Between Two Guys
  4. – 28 Tips to Choose Between Two Guys When You Just Don’t Know for Sure
  5. – How To Choose Between Two Guys – 13 Tips To Make The Right Choice

About the Author

Photo of author

Timileyin Olanrewaju

Timileyin is a Content Writer at He has a B.Sc. in Computer Science. Timileyin loves movies, video games, gadgets, and embraces a quality lifestyle. At, he writes relationship articles.

Related Articles

Get in Touch

We're committed to writing accurate content that informs and educates. To learn more, read our Content Writing Policy, Content Review Policy, Anti-plagiarism Policy, and About Us.

However, if this content does not meet your expectations, kindly reach out to us through one of the following means:

  1. Respond to "Was this page helpful?" above
  2. Leave a comment with the "Leave a Comment" form below
  3. Email us at [email protected] or via the Contact Us page.

Leave a Comment

Send this to a friend